Help
Subscribe


GastroHep.com - the global online resource for all aspects of gastroenterology, hepatology and endoscopy

 19 April 2018

Advanced search
GastroHep.com - the global online resource for all aspects of gastroenterology, hepatology and endoscopy Profile of Roy Pounder

Home

News  
Journals
Review Articles
Slide Atlas
Video Clips
Online Books
Advanced Digestive Endoscopy
Classical Cases
Conference Diary
PubMed
International GH Links
USA GH Links
National GH Links
National GI Societies
Other Useful Links




Emails on Gastroenterology and Hepatology
the National AIDS Treatment Advocacy Project
Visit the gastroenterology section of the EUMS

News

Observer consistency for grading of esophagitis by endoscopists

Reproducibility in grading esophagitis is good for both expert endoscopists and trainees, find researchers in the November issue of Gastrointestinal Endoscopy.

News image

fiogf49gjkf04

In this study, researchers from the United States evaluated intra- and inter-observer variability in the endoscopic scoring of esophagitis.

They assessed 2 grading schemes; the Los Angeles and Hetzel-Dent scales.

The team randomly displayed 325 endoscopic photographs of esophagitis, or healed esophagitis, to 9 endoscopist evaluators (4 experts, 5 trainees) by means of a CD-ROM. Each photograph was shown twice.

The evaluators scored each photograph by using both classification schemes.

For experts, intra-observer reproducibility was greater using both Los Angeles and Hetzel-Dent classifications.
Gastrointestinal Endoscopy
The research team used the kappa statistic as a measure of consistency.

The team found that for the trainees, intra-observer reproducibility was good (kappa = 0.436) when using the Los Angeles classification, but marginal ( kappa = 0.395) when using the Hetzel-Dent classification.

However, for the experts, intra-observer reproducibility was better when using both the Los Angeles (kappa = 0.545) and Hetzel-Dent classification (kappa = 0.552).

They also determined that inter-observer consistency for trainees was good when using both classifications (Los Angeles, kappa = 0.459; Hetzel-Dent, kappa = 0.427).

Again, for the expert evaluators, intra-observer reproducibility was better when using both classifications (Los Angeles, kappa = 0.556, Hetzel-Dent, kappa = 0.571).

When using the Los Angeles classification, only 5% and 8% of the photographs were interpreted to be more than 1 grade different from the mean for experts and trainees, respectively.

This same consistency was found by using the Hetzel-Dent classification scheme (experts 5%, trainees 10%).

Dr John Pandolfino's team concluded, "Reproducibility in grading esophagitis was good for both expert endoscopists and fellows, although there was greater consistency among the experts".

"Both the Los Angeles and Hetzel-Dent scoring systems are reproducible".

In a related editorial in the same publication, Dr Worth Boyce, from Florida, USA, discusses the need for an accurate endoscopic diagnosis of reflux esophagitis.

Dr Boyce states, that in order to achieve this, "A generally accepted classification or grading scheme that is easily understood and minimizes the degree of inter-observer disagreement is essential".

Gastrointest Endosc 2002; 56: 639-43, 775-8
29 October 2002

Go to top of page Email this page Email this page to a colleague

 19 April 2018 
Fibrosis in patients with chronic hepatitis B
 19 April 2018 
c-Myc expression and pancreatic cancer
 19 April 2018 
Olmesartan prescription in the USA
 18 April 2018 
Online tool predicts bowel dysfunction severity prior to anterior resection
 18 April 2018 
Hep C treatment for sustained virologic response
 18 April 2018 
Endoscopic necrosectomy reduces risk of death 
 17 April 2018 
Colorectal cancer screening and ethnic inequities
 17 April 2018 
Training programs should consider radiation education for advanced endoscopy fellows
 17 April 2018 
Aspirin and pancreatic cancer
 16 April 2018 
Surgery for colorectal polyps has increased 
 16 April 2018 
Advanced fibrosis can be ruled out in primary health care patients
 16 April 2018 
Antibiotic use and colorectal adenoma
 13 April 2018 
Colorectal cancer cell lines
 13 April 2018 
Infliximab and corticosteroid-free clinical remission in Crohn's
 13 April 2018 
Teduglutide for children with short bowel syndrome
 12 April 2018 
Prescriptions for opiate drugs amongst primary care patients with IBD
 12 April 2018 
Lower GI bleeding related to comorbidity
 12 April 2018 
non–Clostridium difficile bacterial infections in IBD
 11 April 2018 
Physician perception of IBD trial results
 11 April 2018 
Bile acid deficiency in IBS 
 11 April 2018 
Stem cell therapy for fistulas in Crohn's
 10 April 2018 
Overweight in childhood and type 2 diabetes
 10 April 2018 
immunoglobulin G associates with clinical features of IBD
 10 April 2018 
T-cells repertoires in celiac disease
 09 April 2018 
Biomarker tests for colorectal cancer screening
 09 April 2018 
Fecal transplantation in C. difficile infection and treatment outcome 
 09 April 2018 
No weigh-loss drug improved all cardiometabolic risk factors
 06 April 2018 
Colonoscopy and colorectal cancer mortality
 06 April 2018 
Eosinophilic esophagitis and health-related quality of life
 06 April 2018 
Microbiome in athletes vs sedentary subjects
 05 April 2018 
Laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication for GERD treatment
 05 April 2018 
Random biopsies for neoplasia in IBD
 05 April 2018 
Scoring system identifies cancer risk in Barrett's
 04 April 2018 
Alpha‐1 antitrypsin deficiency and liver disease
 04 April 2018 
PPI and risk of stroke
 04 April 2018 
Adjuvant chemotherapy for advanced colon cancer
 29 March 2018 
Worldwide H.pylori prevalence
 29 March 2018 
Prevention of metachronous gastric cancer
 29 March 2018 
Acute lower GI bleeding
 28 March 2018 
Decision aid used by IBD patients
 28 March 2018 
Transition for young adults with IBD
 28 March 2018 
Amitriptyline in functional dyspepsia
 27 March 2018 
Emergency department utilization for IBD 
 27 March 2018 
Management of hemorrhoids in the USA
 27 March 2018 
Adult ulcerative colitis
 26 March 2018 
Biological therapy response in IBD 
 26 March 2018 
Obesity and diverticulosis
 26 March 2018 
Practice guidelines for chronic constipation
 23 March 2018 
Health-related quality of life in eosinophilic esophagitis
 23 March 2018 
Genetics and chronic liver disease
 23 March 2018 
Global prevalence of H.pylori
 22 March 2018 
H. pyloris and gastric cancer
 22 March 2018 
Pancreatitis after IBS treatment 
 22 March 2018 
Mechanisms of action in patients with IBS
 21 March 2018 
Panel markers for early detection of colon cancer

 21 March 2018 
Blood test differentiates celiac disease
 21 March 2018 
Patient characteristics and colonoscopy preparation
 20 March 2018 
Bloody vs coffee-grounds hematemesis
 20 March 2018 
Acute lower GI bleeding in the UK
 20 March 2018 
Therapeutic strategies for IBD

Blackwell Publishing


GastroHep.com is a Blackwell Publishing registered trademark
© 2018 Wiley-Blackwell and GastroHep.com and contributors
Privacy Statement
Disclaimer
About Us